Hagia Sophia-Church, Museum or Mosque?
Hagia Sophia, a monument of unparalleled historical and architectural significance, has undergone numerous transformations throughout its existence. From a Byzantine cathedral to an Ottoman mosque, a secular museum, and most recently, back to a mosque, its history is deeply intertwined with religion, politics, and culture.
The Origins of Hagia Sophia
Hagia Sophia, also known as the Church of Holy Wisdom, was built between 532 and 537 by the Eastern Roman Emperor Justinian. For nearly a millennium, it served as the principal cathedral of Eastern Christianity until 1453, when Sultan Mehmed II converted it into a mosque following the Ottoman conquest of Constantinople.
Hagia Sophia is an essential part of our Istanbul Tours. You can explore our Istanbul Private Tours here.
Transition from Church to Mosque
Rather than destroying the iconic structure, the Ottomans preserved it as a place of worship. Christian symbols such as mosaics and statues were either plastered over or left visible, while Islamic elements like minarets, a mihrab, and a minbar were added over time. Hagia Sophia remained a mosque for nearly five centuries.
Hagia Sophia as a Museum
In 1934, Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, the founder of the Republic of Turkey, transformed Hagia Sophia into a museum, symbolizing Turkey's secular reforms. Christian mosaics were uncovered and restored, creating a unique blend of Byzantine and Ottoman architectural elements. For decades, it served as a museum of universal cultural heritage.
The 2020 Reconversion to a Mosque
After 86 years, in July 2020, a Turkish court restored Hagia Sophia's status as a mosque. The decision was based on the claim that the 1934 conversion violated the waqf (Islamic law) established by Sultan Mehmed II. The building's custodianship was transferred to the Presidency of Religious Affairs, with promises to conserve Christian icons and maintain part of the site as a fee-free museum.
Reactions to the Reconversion
The reconversion has sparked debates worldwide:
- Christian Perspectives: Many Christians view it as a threat to Christian spirituality and cultural history.
- Turkish Society: Turks remain divided; some celebrate its return to a mosque, while others prefer its secular museum status.
- Global Muslim Community: Opinions vary, with some praising the decision and others fearing it could provoke backlash against Muslim minorities in other countries.
Hagia Sophia: A Political Symbol
The reconversion aligns with Turkey's geopolitical aspirations in the Middle East and Islamic world, especially as its EU membership prospects have dimmed. It also reflects a broader political strategy, possibly aimed at consolidating support among conservative and religious voters in Turkey.
The Cultural Layers of Hagia Sophia
Some critics argue that Hagia Sophia should remain a universal museum, celebrating its Christian, Ottoman, and secular histories equally. Others emphasize its Islamic heritage as a symbol of Ottoman conquest. A potential compromise could involve designating separate spaces for Christian and Muslim worship, preserving its identity as a site of shared cultural significance.